Tonight I am going to come clean. Admit a huge psychological problem. Time to tell you the ugly truth.
And the reason I can share this truth with you tonight is: I am almost cured.
Almost.
But it’s been a long haul, a long road.
Imagine yourself moving to your Little House in the Big Woods. (I am suddenly fascinated with the parallels between this life and the Laura Wilder Ingall’s Little House on the Prairie books that I read to my children before they could toddle. Well before they started kindergarten anyway.) Imagine yourself building an idyllic little cabin in the woods and raising children who ran wild and free building forts and playing amidst the trees.
Really imagine what this feels like. You are surrounded by trees. Trees everywhere. Trees to the left, trees to the right, trees behind you, trees in front of you. You carve out a space for a house and perhaps garage and lawn, but you’re in the forest.
What does this mean? It means there is no visible horizon. You cannot see the sun set or rise, except through the blanket of tree branches. You are always surrounded. Your sight can no longer stretch infinitely to the north or west or east or south. It stops. It stops when it meets trees.
And you have to learn to live in this forest-world, without the gift of a horizon.
So I must tell you the ugly secret. For much of my life here in the wood I have experienced horizon envy. Envy of those who have a horizon. Yes. It was quite painful. In the early years I begged my forest-loving husband “Please can we move down by the water? I must have a view! I must have a horizon!” But my pleas fell on deaf ears. He loved the woods. He couldn’t imagine what his crazy wife was talking about. And I certainly couldn’t articulate about horizon envy.

Sunset in a mud puddle (this is as good as it gets!)
The years passed. I scurried on down to the lake as often as possible. The kids and I camped on the doorstep of the neighbors for a long stretch. Well, actually we kept inviting ourselves for coffee. Because they were such wonderful people and because (this gets really ugly, I know): they had a horizon.
Until one day I started looking at the Little Things. The tiny plants. The texture of bark. The mosses. The leaves. Really looking deeply. Appreciating what was there under my feet and all around in the forest. Wow! Details that had never before been noticed. Subtle gifts.
The forest came alive and suddenly, one of those days, I realized I was no longer desiring the horizon. Well, not as much anyway. There still is a little bit of horizon envy. It may never go away. Especially when the best sunset you can sometimes view is a reflection in a mud puddle in your driveway.
Pa Ingalls moved his family out to the prairie. They left the Big Woods and moved to a place where the horizon was all they could see. No more being surrounded with trees. They were on the big wide expanse of endless view.
Nope, not me. I’ve decided. I like this woods just fine. As long as there is a lake you can walk to a quarter mile away. There are Michigan mountains in this county, as well. You can climb ‘em and admire the horizon all you want. And some of my friends have farms. Fields stretch in all directions around their house. You can go and breathe deep and feel like you are an eagle, looking in all directions at once.
My friend Melinda visited from California once in the middle of our green and leafy summer. She lives atop a mountain. She couldn’t get over the claustrophobic feeling of being surrounded by trees.
I understood what she meant.
Yet I have learned that sometimes the things we need to see next are given to us in life. I needed to open my eyes and look at the little details, the little things. Some people may need the wider view, to live atop a mountain or beside the sea. Sometimes what we want aren’t the same things we need.
Yep. That’s what I’ve learned from this challenging case of Horizon Envy.






20 comments
Comments feed for this article
November 23, 2009 at 10:12 pm
Dawn
I get it. If I had my druthers I’d be on the eastern side of a lake, looking unfettered westward. But I also have a fantasy of building the perfect small house in the middle of my own 40 acres. Or so. Just lately I’ve begun to appreciate the place I actually DO live. Right now. Right here. It’s a good feeling.
November 24, 2009 at 7:08 pm
centria
Dawn, isn’t it great when we get to the point where we start to appreciate where we are, right now? It is the BEST feeling. (But I like your lake fantasy a lot!)
November 24, 2009 at 1:15 am
melinda
ah yes, mountain top melinda here. happened along today. smiling now. i remember so much of those woods. the empty birch barks, big and small everywhere. the fresh smell. the variety of greens and shapes. the crunches and birdsongs. eagle feathers and the sneak by the neighbor and oh yes… the cat. still smiling. i myself, have pine and fir envy. i mostly have blue oaks, grand and stately twisted old grandmothers. the leaves are almost greyish green and oh!, i am surrounded. i yearn for green and green some more, pure green, dark green, fresh green, pointy green and heart shaped green, and oh! deep green… i yearn for the river and the firs and pines… and i yearn and yearn… and here i am with the grandmothers and the aunties. and on this hill i can see far. i am looking east towards you and the Michigan woods on the UP. up and up are you on the? you see far too.
November 24, 2009 at 7:10 pm
centria
mountaintop melinda! I am so very glad you happened by the very post that mentioned your very name! How ’bout we trade? I’ll send you some green (well, maybe not at THIS time of year) and you send me some mountaintop view? Well, maybe not. What IS it about us humans anyway and our yearnings for “the other side of the mountain”? Anyway I really don’t want to say any more about wanting a view or goodness knows a tornado or wildfire will rip through and flatten everything and the universe will say, “Kathy, how you like your view NOW?” Yikes!
November 24, 2009 at 3:14 am
flandrumhill
I don’t have a horizon around my home either but I do love to see the rising sun or moon shining through the trees. The vast horizon lines in the marsh or the nearby beach give me something to walk out for.
November 24, 2009 at 7:11 pm
centria
Amy, the very best part of living in the woods in the sun or moon shining through the trees. And aren’t we lucky that we only need to walk a short ways to see that vast horizon?
November 24, 2009 at 7:48 am
Cindy Lou
I remember moving to NE Montana and the vastness of the sky and prairie….no trees! It took me a while to appreciate that vastness and when I go back, there’s a part of my soul that gives a big breath of ease to be in the midst of it again. I was claustraphobic the first time I came home to the UP, too!
The hardest thing for me would be not to be near water…I did miss that in MT! Water seems to be a touchstone for me.
November 24, 2009 at 7:13 pm
centria
Cindy, you know the prairie (the more I think about) sounds a little scary too. Like maybe a compromise would be good. Part horizon, part trees. Hmmm, I’ve just described my childhood home… Interesting that you were claustrophobic when you first came here too. Oh and when we moved to Texas for that short while, it was awful because there was no water. We take the water breezes for granted here sometimes, I think.
November 24, 2009 at 10:59 am
karen
I always miss the security of the trees, much like the security blanket I dragged around with me as a child. The vast horizons of the prairie and the desert are awesome, but leave me feeling a bit insecure and somewhat naked, My spirit is nurtured by this wild landscape of the U.P.
November 24, 2009 at 7:15 pm
centria
Karen, Barry was talking last night about the security of the trees. That’s the same feeling he gets, I think. I wonder if perhaps people who live on the prairies and deserts are somehow more open than those of us amidst our trees? It’s interesting how landscape informs us, sometimes in subtle ways.
November 24, 2009 at 11:12 am
p.j. grath
In Conrad Richter’s THE TREES, the head of the household takes his wife and young children from Pennsylvania, where he can live in the woods without neighbors. Even after he cuts down enough trees to build their cabin, the forest is so thick that they have no patch of sky. In O. E. Rolvaag’s GIANTS IN THE EARTH, the pioneer wife has nothing but horizon and sky and goes around the bend mentally after her husband whitewashes the inside of their sod house, thinking to brighten it up for her.
Somewhere I heard that happiness is not getting what we want but wanting what we get. Sounds like you’re getting there.
November 24, 2009 at 7:16 pm
centria
No patch of sky at all? That would be…so claustrophobic.
And living with only horizon…too naked and vulnerable.
Hmmm.
I like your philosophy.
Let’s go for it!
November 24, 2009 at 2:03 pm
sahlah
How interesting – horizon envy… I’d never thought of it like that. I can’t imagine ever living inland. I like to see water everyday.
You are really lucky to have both trees and horizon. I love how you give voice to so many thoughts. Were you a teacher too?
November 24, 2009 at 7:17 pm
centria
Dawn, I thought about your comment for the last hour or so. The main character in my NaNoWriMo novel is a teacher. So, even though I am not a teacher, there’s probably an inner one that lives inside and is attempting to come out through these blogs. Thank you for the appreciation, dear friend.
December 19, 2009 at 7:39 pm
Memories can make you cry… « Opening the door, walking outside
[...] those neighborhood dogs hounded in on my walk. And, finally, his sociologist side really enjoyed Horizon Envy, written in late November. The robin that made US [...]
June 21, 2010 at 3:25 pm
The Solstice and the Creature « Lake Superior Spirit
[...] blog which articulated some of the challenges of living amidst a forest of trees. It was called Horizon Envy and it was one of my favorite blogs from last year. My sociologist son even suggested a possible [...]
November 23, 2010 at 7:24 am
Elisa's Spot
I have missed reading these every morning. I wonder if I am to go back and catch up (punitively of course–unsure which one of us might be more punitized from this approach), or just rejoin the river moving toward that horizon.
The insides simply stampede across all of what lies in the way of the horizon for me, I wonder if it might be a remnant of feeling that when one ‘got there’, one might fall off of the earth. Nah, that’s bull poop. I still focus on one shiny rock and miss the pebbles along the way. If I lament upon this for too long, I miss more as I go along. choices choices!!
November 23, 2010 at 8:53 pm
Kathy
Hi, Elisa! Is your computer fixed now or are you still at the library? This was one of my favorite blogs from last year. Know what you mean about choices, though. We must stop lamenting.
November 23, 2010 at 10:28 pm
Elisa's Spot
It appears as though it is fixed now! I think I typed lies when I should have typed lay….I do not think that I ever did figure that out!
September 2, 2011 at 6:45 pm
Horizon Envy (Take Two) « Lake Superior Spirit
[...] a dozen sunset photos from my visit to Yale last month and remembered an old blog called “Horizon Envy” from November 23, 2009 (one month from the end of my year-long outdoor commitment on Opening [...]